Background: HIV-associated lipodystrophy is characterized by wasting of subcutaneous
fat, and the accumulation of visceral, chest, and/or dorso-cervical
fat, with or without metabolic derangements. In the subset designated as HARS
the accumulation of visceral adipose tissue (VAT) may constitute a risk for
cardiovascular disease and type II diabetes, and lead to local symptoms and
dissatisfaction with antiviral. For a controlled study of growth hormone to
reduce VAT in HARS a key issue has been to devise a simple, effective means to
select study-eligible patients with HARS, emphasizing VAT accumulation and not
simple obesity. A previous discriminant function
based on waist (WC) and hip (HC) circumference and the ratio WC:HC (WHR) was specific and sensitive in detection of
clinically diagnosed HARS. Here we demonstrate that use of similar
anthropometric criteria to select HARS patients defines a group radiologically distinct from healthy controls (C).
Methods:
31 M and 11 F HIV+ adults met the eligibility criteria: WC > 88.2 cm (male); 75.3 (female) and WHR
≥0.95 (male); 0.9 (female), and were compared with 300 C (128 male 172
female). VAT and Subcutaneous AT (SAT) are expressed as cross-sectional areas
on CT or MRI (C) scans at the L4-5 level.
Results
(mean±SD,
p values for t-test):
|
|
BMI (kg.m-2)
|
SAT (cm2)
|
VAT (cm2)
|
|
|
Male
Female FEMALE
|
Male
Female
|
Male
Female
|
|
Pts
|
26.9±2.7 26.6±4.8
|
176.6±88 282.9±118
|
196.4±99 110.4±37
|
|
C
|
25.5±3.8 25.4±5.3
|
166.1±90 231.4±137
|
73.3±60 56.2±49
|
|
p
|
ns ns
|
ns ns
|
<0.001 <0.001
|
The 95% confidence bounds of VAT in HARS
patients thus selected can be used to distinguish patients from C with a
specificity of 94% for males and 85% for females.
Conclusions:
use of WC and WHR criteria applied to HIV+ patients selects a population of
marginally higher BMI and SAT than C but whose VAT is 2-3 x greater than C.
Thus, the criteria define a population suitable for entry into a therapeutic
trial for patients with HARS with specific large increases in VAT, rather than
nonspecific obesity.