129
In Chronic HIV-1 infection, Cyclosporine A Provides No Sustained Immunologic Benefit to Persons Starting ART
Michael Lederman*1, L Smeaton2, K Smith3, B Rodriguez1, H Wang2, P Tebas4, S Sieg1, D Margolis5, C Pilcher5, H Valdez6, and AIDS Clinical Trials Group A5138 team
1Case Western Reserve Univ, Cleveland, OH, US; 2Statistical & Data Analysis Ctr, Harvard Univ, Boston, MA, US; 3Rush Med Coll, Chicago, IL, US; 4Univ of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, US; 5Univ of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, US; and 6Boehringer Ingelheim
Background: While the determinants of immune deficiency
and immune restoration in chronic HIV-1 infection are not well understood, immune
activation has been proposed as central to HIV pathogenesis. An earlier
uncontrolled study indicated that co-administration of cyclosporine A (CsA)
with initial ART to persons with recent HIV infection increased CD4 T-cell
recovery dramatically.
Methods: We performed a randomized controlled trial of
2 weeks of CsA vs no CsA during the first 2 weeks of standardized ART vs
standardized ART among 42 persons with chronic HIV-1 infection, CD4 T
cells >100/µL, and plasma HIV-1 RNA ≥5000
copies/mL. Enrollees were mostly males (93%) and white (57%). Median age was
37, baseline CD4 cell count was 269/µL and HIV RNA 5.0 log10. For the first 2 weeks patients recieved zidovudine, lamivudine, and
abacavir. At 2 weeks, efavirenz was added. CsA levels were monitored and
dosage was adjusted to maintain levels between 250 and 450 ng/mL. The
study had an 80% power to detect a 75-cell greater CD4+ T-cell
change from baseline to week 8 in the CsA plus ART group.
Results: Coadministration of CsA provided a significant increase in
CD4 T-cell restoration at days 3 and 7 (median +140 and +128 cells/µL vs +17
and +31 cells/µL in the no-CsA group, p
<0.002), but by day 14 and through week 48, these significant differences
were no longer observed. The early enhancement in circulating T-cell
restoration was largely restricted to T cells expressing the CCR7 chemokine
receptor. CsA did not affect plasma HIV
RNA decay or the sustained suppression of HIV replication. At 48 weeks 76 and
79% of persons had plasma HIV RNA <50 copies/mL in the CsA and no-CsA
groups, respectively. Assays of T-cell expansion and antibody responses to
hepatitis A vaccine in vitro were
unaffected by CsA administration, but antibody responses to rabies vaccine were
attenuated. There were 3 HIV-related diagnoses in the CsA arm vs 1 in the
no-CsA arm.
Conclusions: CsA coadministered for the first 2 weeks of
ART did not provide sustained immunologic benefit to persons with chronic HIV-1
infection. The modest accelerated increase in circulating
CCR7+ T cells likely reflects early release from sequestration in
lymphoid tissues. If immune activation drives progressive immune deficiency in
chronic HIV-1 infection, these activation pathways may not be
cyclosporine-sensitive; other pathways of immune activation should be pursued.
|