684
Evaluating Testing Strategies for Early HIV Diagnosis in Children
Robert Downing*1, J Homsy1, P Elyanu2, J Kalamya1, P Musoke2, M Fowler2, S Fiscus3, T Finkbeiner4, S Balinandi1, and B West1
1Global AIDS Prgm, CDC Uganda, Entebbe; 2Makerere Univ, Kampala, Uganda; 3Univ of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, US; and 4Natl Ctr for HIV, Viral Hepatitis, STD, and TB Prevention, Global AIDS Prgm, CDC, Atlanta, GA, US
Background: Focusing on HIV treatment, African countries are
rolling out national programs for early infant HIV diagnosis, targeting both perinatal follow-up clinics and maternal and child health immunization
clinics. Regionalized polymerase chain reaction (PCR) testing is planned but shipment
of blood poses logistic challenges. The use of dried blood spots (DBS) simplifies
shipment but has not been validated in Uganda.
Methods: Whole blood specimens were collected from HIV-exposed
children (mean age 22.6 weeks; range 6 to 84 weeks) at a perinatal
follow-up clinic, a hospital ward, and a maternal and child health clinic. Cell
pellets (CP) were prepared for Amplicor DNA (AMPD),
DBS for Amplicor DNA, and total nucleic acid (TNA) and
plasma for ultra-sensitive HIV p24 antigen (UP24Ag) assay. Results were
compared against a “gold-standard.”
Results: Results
with the AMPD and TNA assays on DBS were in complete agreement and had good
sensitivity (96.0%) and specificity (94.9%) compared to AMPD on CP; UP24Ag had slightly
lower values (90.7% and 94.2%). Between CP and DBS on AMPD, 11 specimens gave
discordant results; repeat testing, UP24Ag and TNA results, when available, was
in complete agreement with the DBS result on AMPD, suggesting that AMPD on DBS
is a better gold-standard than AMPD on CP. Re-analysis using AMPD on DBS as the
gold-standard gave much improved values for TNA and UP24Ag.
Conclusions: In this study, DBS out-performed CP as the
specimen of choice for HIV PCR-based testing in terms of both accuracy and
convenience; UP24Ag on plasma proved to be an acceptable alternative. The use
of DBS PCR or plasma UP24Ag for testing should expedite rapid scale-up of early
infant diagnosis in resource-limited settings.
|
Assay
|
Gold-Standard
|
N
|
SN
(%)
|
SP
(%)
|
PPV
(%)
|
NPV
(%)
|
|
AMPD-DBS
|
AMPD-CP
|
238
|
96.0
|
94.9
|
93.3
|
97.0
|
|
AMPD-CP
|
AMPD-DBS
|
238
|
93.3
|
97.0
|
96.8
|
94.9
|
|
TNA-DBS
|
AMPD-CP
|
239
|
96.0
|
94.9
|
93.3
|
97.0
|
|
|
AMPD-DBS
|
509
|
100
|
100
|
100
|
100
|
|
UP24Ag
|
AMPD-CP
|
179
|
90.7
|
94.2
|
91.9
|
93.3
|
|
|
AMPD-DBS
|
204
|
94.3
|
98.3
|
97.6
|
95.8
|
|