778 
A 2-Months-off/4-Months-on HAART Is Clinically Not Inferior to Continuous Therapy but Leads to Unacceptable Resistance Rates in African Adults with >350 CD4/mm3 at First Interruption: Final Results of the Trivacan Trial
Christine Danel*1, R Moh1, M L Chaix2, D Gabillard3, B Kouadio1, T Toni4, C Rouzioux2, R Salamon3, E Bissagnene5, X Anglaret3, and ANRS 1269 study group
1Prgm PACCI, Abidjan, Côte d`Ivoire; 2Ctr Hosp Univ Necker, Paris, France; 3INSERM U593, Bordeaux, France; 4CeDReS, Abidjan, Côte d`Ivoire; and 5Infectious and Tropical Diseases Svc, Abidjan, Côte d`Ivoire
Background: Fixed cycle scheduled treatment
interruptions (F-STI) have been evaluated in patients with low pre-HAART CD4
count in East Africa and high pre-HAART CD4 count in other continents. We
report the results of a fixed cycle 2-months-off/4-months-on HAART trial in
patients with high pre-HAART CD4 count in West Africa.
Methods: We randomized 651 adults with a median pre-HAART CD4 count of
272/μL, current on-HAART CD4 count >350 CD4/μL, and
undetectable viral load into a non-inferiority trial including 3 arms: continuous
HAART (CT); CD4-guided HAART; and 2-months-off/4-months-on HAART. There were 3
primary endpoints: mortality (non-inferiority bound –5), severe HIV-morbidity
(WHO stage 3- or 4-events or death) ( non-inferiority bound –15), and
percentage of patients with >350 CD4/μL at 24
months (non-inferiority bound +15). Secondary endpoints were cost, resistance,
adherence, and toxicity. The CD4-guided arm was prematurely interrupted because
of a high rate of morbidity. The continuous heart and 2-months-off/4-months-on arms
were continued until trial termination (the last patient reaching 24 months of
follow-up, March 2007). We report the results of the final analysis.
Results: We randomized 435 adults (zidovudine-lamivudine-efavirenz [ZDV-3TC-EFV],
88%) into the continuous and 2-months-off/4-months-on arms. For all primary
endpoints, the 2-months-off/4-months-on arm was not inferior to the continuous
arm: The incidence or mortality was 0.45/100 person-years in the continuous
therapy are and 0.46/100 person-years in the2-months-off/4-months-on arm (lower
bound of the unilateral 95%CI for difference –0.87: > –5 NIB); the
incidence of severe HIV morbidity was 6.8/100 person-years in continuous and
9.1/100 person-years in the2-months-off/4-months-on arms (lower bound of 95%CI –6.0:
> –15 NIB); the 24-month percentage of patients with >350 CD4/μL was
94% in continuous and 85% in 2-months-off/4-months-on arm (upper bound of 95%CI
+14: <+15 NIB). As regards secondary endpoints, the overall cost of care was
higher in continuous than in the 2-months-off/4-months-on arm ($960/person-year
vs $785/person-year, p <0.0001) and the 24-month percentage of
patients with at least one ARV drug resistance was lower in continuous than in 2-months-off/4-months-on
arms (9% vs 21%, p = 0.007). Most resistance mutations were to NNRTI
(62%) and lamivudine/emtricitabine (3TC/FTC; 23%). There was no difference
between arms in terms of adherence, grade-3 to -4 toxicity, severe non-HIV
morbidity, hypertension, dyslipidemia, hyperglycemia, and lipodystrophy.
Conclusions: In these patients, predominantly EFV-treated and with high
CD4 nadir and >350 CD4/μL at first interruption, the
2-months-off/4-months-on HAART was clinically not inferior to continuous
therapy, but led to unacceptable resistance rates.
|