992
A Clinical Study of Antigen/Antibody Rapid Testing for Acute HIV Infection
Christopher Pilcher*1, B Louie2, S Keating3, M Pandori2, F Fish4, T Keren4, M Lebedeva3, S Liska2, M Busch3, and F Hecht1
1Univ of California, San Francisco, US; 2San Francisco Publ Hlth Lab, CA, US; 3Blood Systems Res Inst, San Francisco, CA, US; and 4Inverness Med Innovations
Background: Existing approaches to diagnosing acute
HIV infection (e.g., RNA pooling) are unsuitable for point-of-care screening
and cannot be used in resource-limited settings. The newly introduced Determine
HIV-½ Ag/Ab Combo is the first simple-to-use, rapid (20 to 30 minute) HIV test to
be introduced that detects both p24 antigen and anti-HIV antibodies. p24
antigen and antibody are detected as separate lines on the assay.
Methods: We evaluated the diagnostic performance of novel,
rapid test-only acute HIV screening algorithms in the University of California–San F rancisco Options acute HIV infection screening program. Eligible subjects had
symptoms consistent with an acute retroviral syndrome or a high risk exposure
to HIV, with a negative HIV test result within 12 months. For this study we
tested all subjects using the Determine rapid Ag/Ab test, and the Clearview
StatPak rapid Ab test; we defined HIV status using a series of gold-standard
tests: a third-generation high-sensitivity HIV antibody enzyme immunoassay
(Vitros ECi); individual specimen HIV RNA (Roche); HIV WB (Biorad); and a
less-sensitive modification of the Vitros assay to define recent HIV infection (LS-Vitros;
cutoff S/C<14).
Results: Among 168 subjects tested, 87 were HIV–
and 81 were HIV+ (9 acute; 59 recent; 13 long-term infections by
LS-Vitros assay). Used as a single screening assay, the Determine rapid Ag/Ab test
identified 79 of 81 (97.5%) HIV infections, including 7 of 9 (77.8%) StatPak
rapid Ab-nonreactive acute HIV infections. The 2 specimens that were missed by
both the Determine rapid Ag/Ab and StatPak rapid Ab test had >500,000 copies
HIV RNA/mL and also very low level antibodies (detectable only by the Vitros
ECi assay, but undetectable by the LS-Vitros assay (S/C <0.1). The Determine
rapid Ag/Ab test gave one false positive result.
|
Algorithm
|
Sens (95CI)
|
Spec (95CI)
|
|
Rapid Ag/Ab Combo (Determine)
|
97.5 (92.4 to 99.6)
|
98.9 (94.3 to 99.9)
|
|
Rapid Ag/Ab + Ab (Determine+StatPak)
|
97.5 (92.4 to 99.6)
|
100 (96.4 to 100)
|
|
Rapid Ab test (StatPak)
|
88.9 (80.9 to 94.5)
|
100 (96.4 to 100)
|
|
Non-rapid, sensitive Ab test (Vitros ECi)
|
95.1 (88.8 to 98.5)
|
100 (96.4 to 100)
|
Conclusions: The Determine rapid HIV Ag/Ab test
appears to have sufficient clinical performance to merit full scale trials of acute
HIV screening. Successful introduction of an effective point-of-care screening
test for acute HIV infection would have implications for HIV testing and HIV
prevention programs, and for the conduct of pathogenesis and prevention trials.
|