921
Validation and Quality Assurance of the Infant Diagnostic PCR Test Using a Second Spot from the Same Dried Blood Spot Sample in Nigeria
Chin-Yih Ou*1, O Bolu1, K Bond2, R Audu1, A Abimiku3, K Diallo1, L Lu1, T Jelpe2, M Okoye4, A Abubakar2, and Federal Ministry of Health: Dr. E Ngige and Dr. Akinsete; Dr. John Vertifeuhille: CDC,Abuja, Nigeria
1CDC, Atlanta, GA, US; 2CDC Nigeria, Abuja; 3Inst of Human Virology, Jos, Nigeria; and 4USAID, Abuja, Nigeria
Background: Early diagnosis of HIV infection in
exposed infants is critical to prompt access to care and treatment. Dried blood
spot (DBS) -based DNA polymerase chain reaction (PCR) is the method of choice
in resource-limited settings. Nigeria embarked on a demonstration project from
February to August 2007 to evaluate testing algorithms and quality assurance procedures.
Methods: DBS samples were collected from HIV-exposed
children, aged 6 weeks to 18 months, and tested in a central laboratory by Roche
Amplicor DNA PCR v. 1.5 using 6-mm disks. Initial positive samples were
retested using second disks from the same DBS samples. If both tests were
positive, the sample was reported positive. If the second test was negative,
the sample was further investigated: 10% of negative, all positive, and all discordant
samples were further tested in a secondary lab for additional quality assurance.
Both laboratories were enrolled in an external proficiency program.
Results: Of the 561 samples tested, 123 (21.9%) were
initially positive and confirmed by second tests from the same DBS cards in the
primary laboratory. Of the initial positive samples, 31 were found to be negative
due to laboratory errors. Of these, 18 errors were a result of a run involving
a new technical staff member. However, because of the retesting requirement for
positive samples, these errors were recognized prior to the release of test
results. For additional quality assurance/quality control, 97 positive samples
were examined by a quality assurance laboratory; 96 (99%) were found positive
and 1 was found negative. This negative sample was investigated and found to
yield 4 negative, 1 indeterminate, and 2 positive results indicating that its
HIV DNA content was at the level of detection threshold. We retested 40
negative samples in the quality assurance laboratory: 39 were found to be
negative and 1 was indeterminate.
Conclusions: Establishing a public health program of
PCR-based infant diagnostic testing in resource-limited settings requires close
monitoring and quality assurance. Performing DNA PCR on a second disk from the
same DBS sample confirms the initial results and reduces errors. Laboratory staff
training and strengthening of the quality assurance system are critical to producing
reliable results. Countries currently limited to testing just one DBS spot may
consider adopting the approach outlined here. The cost-benefit of this approach
merits further evaluation and comparisons with collecting and testing a second
DBS sample from infants before performing another test.
|